20 Creamy Homemade Popsicles Better Than Store-Bought

Love the idea of making homemade popsicles, but they always turn out like a chunk of ice? We found 20 homemade popsicles that are anything but hard, flavorless ice.

You may want to try our easy ice cream sandwich milkshake. It’s so good and a family favorite. Give it a try!

Creamy Homemade Popsicles

There are things you can do at home to make your popsicles creamy, rather than nothing more than a frozen chunk of barely flavored ice. The popsicle recipes below will take your ice cream game to another level. Prepare to drool.

Strawberry Ice Cream Popsicles – Make sure you use full-fat yogurt for a nicer consistency. Ice cream is not the place to try and cut fat.

Strawberry Paletas – This has a cream base for a rich, smooth frozen treat.

Nutella Popsicles – This recipe uses Cool Whip, Nutella, and whole milk. (Never use anything less than full-fat dairy if you’re looking for creamy rather than icy.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Fudge Popsicles – Holy cow. I’m all the way in on this recipe.

Creamy Banana Pops – Whole milk and heavy cream are the keys to keeping the popsicles creamy.

Coconut Lemon Popsicles – Coconut milk really takes this recipe up a notch.

Dulce De Leche Lemon Popsicles – Condensed milk just makes everything better, in my humble opinion.

Orange Creamsicle Popsicles – Only 5 ingredients and you have homemade creamsicles.

Creamy Watermelon Popsicles with Magic Shell – Tell me these don’t look incredible. PS: She even teaches you how to make your own Magic Shell!

Creamy Watermelon Popsicles – This yummy recipe is a little different than above and doesn’t use chocolate – if you are a watermelon purist.

Lavender Cream and Strawberry – This popsicle recipe is via video, so I can’t share a photo. Trust me, it just screams summer.

Creamy Fudgesicles – This one adds melted chocolate chips. I think these look exactly like the ones you buy in the store. Betcha they’re way better, too.

Classic Pudding Pops – An old favorite for moms to make. If your Mom made these when you were a kid, you had a good thing going.

Creamy Peach Popsicles – Featuring ripe peaches, vanilla yogurt, almond milk, and honey.

Butterscotch Popsicles – I’ve never had them, but they definitely sound good.

Strawberry Cheesecake Popsicles – I was so surprised at the ingredient list. Never would have thought to use pie filling.

Vanilla Popsicles – I love this idea because you make the vanilla base to use as is, or use one of her recipes that adds something to the base to kick it up a notch.