Love the idea of making homemade popsicles, but they always turn out like a chunk of ice? We found 20 homemade popsicles that are anything but hard, flavorless ice.
You may want to try our easy ice cream sandwich milkshake. It’s so good and a family favorite. Give it a try!
Creamy Homemade Popsicles
There are things you can do at home to make your popsicles creamy, rather than nothing more than a frozen chunk of barely flavored ice. The popsicle recipes below will take your ice cream game to another level. Prepare to drool.
Strawberry Ice Cream Popsicles – Make sure you use full-fat yogurt for a nicer consistency. Ice cream is not the place to try and cut fat.
Strawberry Paletas – This has a cream base for a rich, smooth frozen treat.
Nutella Popsicles – This recipe uses Cool Whip, Nutella, and whole milk. (Never use anything less than full-fat dairy if you’re looking for creamy rather than icy.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Fudge Popsicles – Holy cow. I’m all the way in on this recipe.
Creamy Banana Pops – Whole milk and heavy cream are the keys to keeping the popsicles creamy.
Coconut Lemon Popsicles – Coconut milk really takes this recipe up a notch.
Dulce De Leche Lemon Popsicles – Condensed milk just makes everything better, in my humble opinion.
Orange Creamsicle Popsicles – Only 5 ingredients and you have homemade creamsicles.
Creamy Watermelon Popsicles with Magic Shell – Tell me these don’t look incredible. PS: She even teaches you how to make your own Magic Shell!
Creamy Watermelon Popsicles – This yummy recipe is a little different than above and doesn’t use chocolate – if you are a watermelon purist.
Lavender Cream and Strawberry – This popsicle recipe is via video, so I can’t share a photo. Trust me, it just screams summer.
Creamy Fudgesicles – This one adds melted chocolate chips. I think these look exactly like the ones you buy in the store. Betcha they’re way better, too.
Classic Pudding Pops – An old favorite for moms to make. If your Mom made these when you were a kid, you had a good thing going.
Creamy Peach Popsicles – Featuring ripe peaches, vanilla yogurt, almond milk, and honey.
Butterscotch Popsicles – I’ve never had them, but they definitely sound good.
Strawberry Cheesecake Popsicles – I was so surprised at the ingredient list. Never would have thought to use pie filling.
Vanilla Popsicles – I love this idea because you make the vanilla base to use as is, or use one of her recipes that adds something to the base to kick it up a notch.
Banana Pudding Pops – This recipe only has 3 ingredients! So easy to make.
Almond Joy Popsicles – The candy bar is a fave, so I bet this is amazing.
Sher Bailey has been a dedicated voice for the Love and Marriage blog for over a decade, sharing practical advice on everything from stretching a grocery budget to finding the best homeschooling resources. She writes from the unique perspective of a full-time traveler, living and working on the road in her motorhome alongside her husband and their two cats. Sher’s diverse body of work is fueled by her belief that with the right tools and a little creativity, any challenge can be turned into an opportunity for growth and adventure.
Leave a Reply